BDC Investing: How Business Development Companies Generate Dividend Income

Business development companies give individual investors access to private credit and middle-market lending through publicly traded shares.

Their dividends can be substantial, but a BDC is not simply a stock with a large yield. It is a professionally managed lending business whose results depend on recurring interest income, borrower credit quality, financing costs, leverage and management discipline.

Understanding those moving parts is the key to distinguishing durable BDC income from a dividend that may be approaching trouble.

What Is a Business Development Company?

A business development company, commonly called a BDC, is a type of closed-end investment company created to finance primarily small and middle-market businesses.

BDCs commonly invest in:

• First-lien loans
• Second-lien loans
• Subordinated debt
• Unsecured loans
• Preferred shares
• Common equity
• Warrants
• Structured-credit investments

Many of the businesses financed by BDCs are privately owned and cannot borrow as easily or cheaply as large public corporations.

This creates an opportunity for BDCs to earn higher interest rates and fees. It also exposes shareholders to risks that are different from those found in conventional dividend-paying companies.

The SEC describes publicly traded BDCs as complex investments with unique risks, including exposure to private companies, illiquid loans, leverage and potentially higher fees. Read the SEC’s BDC investor guidance.

How a BDC Makes Money

A BDC raises money from shareholders and lenders, then invests that money primarily in loans and other securities issued by portfolio companies.

Its income may include:

• Interest collected on loans
• Loan-origination fees
• Amendment and consent fees
• Prepayment fees
• Dividends from equity investments
• Gains from selling investments
• Payment-in-kind income

The BDC pays its own operating expenses, management fees and interest on borrowed money. What remains contributes to the earnings available for shareholder distributions.

The basic model is straightforward:

Earn more from investments than the combined cost of financing, management and operations.

The execution is considerably harder.

Why BDC Dividends Can Be So High

Many BDCs elect to be treated as regulated investment companies for federal tax purposes.

To maintain that tax treatment, a qualifying company must meet income, asset and distribution requirements. The distribution requirement generally includes at least 90% of investment company taxable income, subject to the detailed tax rules.

Distributing a large portion of taxable income leaves more of the earnings in shareholders’ hands, but it also means BDCs retain less cash than conventional corporations.

That creates an ongoing need to manage liquidity carefully and, in many cases, raise additional financing to expand the investment portfolio.

The IRS requirements are more technical than the common claim that a BDC must simply “pay out 90% of its earnings.” Review the IRS rules for regulated investment companies.

Net Investment Income

Net investment income, or NII, is the starting point for evaluating a BDC dividend.

NII generally includes interest, dividends and fee income earned by the investment portfolio after subtracting management fees, operating expenses and financing costs.

The most useful comparison is:

Recurring NII per share compared with the regular dividend per share.

If a BDC earns ﹩0.45 per share in recurring NII and pays a ﹩0.40 dividend, the dividend has a five-cent earnings cushion for that quarter.

If it earns ﹩0.35 and distributes ﹩0.40, the regular dividend is not fully covered by current NII.

One quarter does not establish a durable trend. Coverage should be reviewed across multiple reporting periods.

Recurring Earnings vs. Temporary Support

Not every dollar included in NII has the same long-term value.

A strong quarter may include:

• Unusually large prepayment fees
• Accelerated loan discounts
• One-time amendment fees
• Incentive-fee waivers
• Income from a temporary investment
• Other items unlikely to repeat

These items are real, but they should not automatically be treated as permanent support for the regular dividend.

Fly High Investing separates recurring earnings from temporary support whenever the information is available.

Read Why Net Investment Income Is the Gold Standard for Evaluating BDC Dividends.

First-Lien and Second-Lien Loans

A first-lien lender generally has the first contractual claim on specified borrower assets if the borrower defaults.

A second-lien lender ranks behind the first-lien lender. Because repayment is less certain, second-lien loans generally charge higher interest rates.

A portfolio containing a large percentage of first-lien loans may have a more defensive structure, but the label alone does not guarantee safety.

Investors must still consider:

• The borrower’s financial condition
• The loan-to-value ratio
• Covenant protections
• Industry exposure
• The quality of the collateral
• The lender’s underwriting discipline

A poorly underwritten first-lien loan can still lose money.

Non-Accrual Loans

A loan is generally placed on non-accrual status when the lender no longer believes ordinary interest collection is sufficiently certain.

When a loan moves to non-accrual, the BDC may stop recognizing some or all of the expected interest income. That can reduce future NII and weaken dividend coverage.

Investors should monitor:

• The number of non-accrual investments
• The amount invested in them
• Whether non-accruals are increasing
• Whether troubled borrowers are concentrated in one industry
• Whether loans are returning to normal payment status
• Realized recoveries and losses

A single troubled loan may have little effect in a highly diversified portfolio. Several large non-accruals can materially change the earnings outlook.

Payment-in-Kind Income

Payment-in-kind income, commonly called PIK, allows a borrower to add interest to its loan balance instead of paying the interest in cash.

PIK is not automatically bad. It may be appropriate for a growing company conserving cash while executing a credible business plan.

However, rising PIK income can create a gap between reported earnings and cash actually collected.

Important questions include:

• What percentage of total investment income is PIK?
• Is PIK concentrated among weaker borrowers?
• Is the borrower also paying part of its interest in cash?
• Is the loan balance growing faster than the borrower’s ability to repay?
• Has management successfully collected similar PIK income in the past?

A BDC relying heavily on PIK to cover its dividend deserves additional scrutiny.

Leverage and Funding Costs

BDCs commonly borrow money to expand their investment portfolios.

Leverage can increase earnings when the yield on the investments exceeds the cost of borrowing. It can also amplify losses, increase interest expense and reduce flexibility during difficult credit markets.

Review:

• Debt-to-equity
• Interest expense
• Fixed-rate and floating-rate borrowing
• Credit-facility terms
• Debt maturities
• Available liquidity
• Unfunded commitments
• Compliance with borrowing requirements

The SEC specifically identifies leverage and debt exposure as important BDC risks. Read the SEC’s publicly traded BDC bulletin.

How Interest Rates Affect BDC Earnings

Many BDC loans carry floating interest rates tied to benchmarks such as SOFR.

When benchmark rates rise, interest collected from floating-rate loans may increase. The benefit depends on interest-rate floors, the amount of fixed and floating borrowing, and whether higher payments weaken borrowers.

Higher rates can improve BDC income while simultaneously increasing borrower stress.

When rates decline, income from floating-rate assets may reset downward. If borrowing costs decline more slowly, the difference between investment income and financing expense can narrow.

The effect of rate changes must be evaluated across both sides of the balance sheet.

External vs. Internal Management

An internally managed BDC employs its own management team. An externally managed BDC pays an outside investment adviser to manage the portfolio.

External management agreements commonly include:

• A base management fee
• An incentive fee based on income
• An incentive fee based on realized gains
• Administrative expense reimbursements

External management is not automatically inferior. Several highly regarded BDCs are externally managed.

The important questions are:

• Are the fees reasonable?
• Do incentives reward sustainable shareholder income?
• Does the manager have a strong underwriting record?
• Are fee waivers temporarily supporting reported results?
• Does the manager issue shares or expand assets primarily to increase fees?

Management structure should be evaluated alongside actual results.

Dividend Coverage Warning Signs

Warning signs may include:

• Recurring NII falling below the regular dividend
• Coverage depending on fee waivers
• Large one-time fees being treated as recurring income
• Rising non-accruals
• Increasing PIK income
• Deteriorating borrower credit quality
• Leverage increasing while earnings weaken
• Funding costs rising faster than investment income
• Repeated dividend reductions
• Large exposure to one borrower or industry
• Management explanations that rely heavily on adjusted results

One warning sign does not automatically disqualify a BDC. Several appearing together can indicate that the income thesis is deteriorating.

A Practical BDC Review

Use this process when reviewing a BDC:

1. Compare recurring NII per share with the regular dividend.
2. Review coverage across at least four quarters.
3. Identify temporary fees, waivers and non-recurring income.
4. Examine non-accrual loans and internal credit ratings.
5. Measure payment-in-kind income as a percentage of total income.
6. Review leverage, liquidity and debt maturities.
7. Evaluate the effect of changing interest rates.
8. Understand management fees and incentives.
9. Examine borrower and industry concentration.
10. Decide whether the current valuation adequately reflects the evidence.

No single metric provides the answer. The objective is to understand how the entire lending business supports the dividend.

BDCs in a Diversified Income Portfolio

BDCs can provide substantial income and exposure to private credit that is difficult for individual investors to obtain directly.

They can also respond similarly to credit conditions. Owning several BDCs does not eliminate the risk of a broad decline in borrower health.

Diversification should consider:

• The number of holdings
• Position sizes
• Borrower markets
• Industry exposure
• Management firms
• Loan seniority
• Interest-rate sensitivity
• Other income-producing structures in the portfolio

A diversified portfolio should not depend excessively on one company, manager or source of earnings.

How Fly High Investing Evaluates BDCs

Fly High Investing evaluates BDCs using the factors most relevant to dividend income:

• Recurring net investment income
• Regular dividend coverage
• Asset quality
• Non-accruals
• Payment-in-kind income
• Leverage and liquidity
• Funding costs
• Management fees
• Valuation
• Dividend durability
• Reinvestment quality

The Fly High 50 Model Portfolio demonstrates how BDCs and other high-income securities can be combined in a diversified research model.

Subscribers receive company profiles, earnings and dividend analysis, Weekend Updates, Performance Tables and Earnings History.

See what a Fly High subscription provides.

BDC Investing Frequently Asked Questions

Are BDC dividends guaranteed?

No. Dividends depend on investment income, credit performance, financing costs, taxable income and decisions made by the board.

Does NII coverage make a BDC safe?

No. NII coverage is essential, but investors must also examine credit quality, leverage, liquidity, fees and whether the reported income is recurring.

Is PIK income always a warning sign?

No. PIK can be appropriate in some lending arrangements. A rising or unusually large concentration of PIK requires additional scrutiny because the income is not being received in cash.

Are first-lien loans safe?

First-lien status provides contractual priority over junior creditors, but it does not eliminate default risk or guarantee full recovery.

Do falling interest rates hurt every BDC?

No. The effect depends on the mix of floating-rate assets, interest-rate floors, fixed and floating borrowing costs, leverage and borrower activity.

Are externally managed BDCs inferior?

Not automatically. The manager’s underwriting record, fees, incentives and treatment of shareholders matter more than the label alone.

Continue Learning

• Investment Income: How to Build and Evaluate a Durable Income Stream
• Why Dividend Yield Alone Isn’t Enough
• Why Earnings Fix Everything
• Dividend Investing: Coverage, Growth, Reinvestment and Risk

This page is provided for general educational and informational purposes. It is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Review our Terms of Services for additional information.